Hearth Pit Or Chiminea – Which One Is The Finest?

Hearth Pit or Chiminea: What’s The Distinction?

There are numerous variations between the 2 constructions equivalent to:


Probably the most distinguishing characteristic is the form of every construction. A hearth pit appears to be like like a big bowl that may both be dug into the bottom or free-standing. Supplies equivalent to wooden are positioned contained in the open hearth pit bowl and ignited to create a hearth. 

A chiminea is a free standing bulbous construction with a chimney on prime to extract smoke. A small opening on the entrance of the chiminea is used so as to add wooden to the fireplace.


Chimineas are typically pricier than hearth pits and vary from £150 as much as £1000. This is because of their elaborate development and the supplies they’re designed with which could be clay, forged iron or aluminium.

Hearth pits are cheaper in value and could be bought for as little as £60, though excessive finish designs can be found. These outside heaters are available in many alternative designs and you’ll even make your very personal distinctive hearth pit which no person else could have!


“There’s no smoke with out hearth.”

Smoke could be harmful if inhaled, notably black smoke, Nonetheless, so long as you might be cautious with what you burn inside a hearth pit or a chiminea then smoke will not be a problem.

Typically, a chiminea is the extra handy choice in relation to smoke because it has a chimney which directs the smoke away and up into the sky. A hearth pit doesn’t have such a characteristic and the slightest little bit of wind could have customers coughing and spluttering which can put a dampener on the second. 

A very good tip is to burn the proper gas equivalent to dry wooden. This can restrict the quantity of smoke making it a extra pleasing (and cough-free) expertise.

Gasoline Measurement

If wooden is your supply of gas (which it usually is), then a hearth pit is ready to take greater items because of its open bowl construction. Additionally, take a look at our article about beginning a hearth pit

A chiminea has a smaller opening which implies smaller items will likely be required which could be irritating in the event you’re working low on gas and you must shortly chop extra.


Most hearth pits are made out of sturdy supplies equivalent to stone, concrete, forged iron and metal. Metal hearth pits are mild in weight which makes it straightforward to maneuver them across the backyard. 

Chimineas are typically fairly heavy, notably when made out of forged iron. Different supplies embody clay and terracotta or metal. Clay chimineas are inclined to break, notably if dropped.

Protecting covers could be bought for each that are really helpful for forged iron as it might (and can) rust if ignored in chilly, wet circumstances.

Utilizing The Product 

Whereas each gadgets are typically straightforward to make use of, it needs to be stated {that a} hearth pit wins this battle. A hearth pit requires not more than a flame to some kindling and also you’re prepared for motion. We have  written an article about cooking on a firepit.

Chimineas, alternatively, can take some time to get going and wish a whole lot of prompting when attempting to carry a flame. They generally want a base layer of sand or gravel to assist keep the fireplace.


Chimineas are sometimes smaller than hearth pits which is nice in case your backyard is on the small facet however laughable when you have acres of land.

Equally, small hearth pits can be found however they do vary dramatically in dimension. Some even being constructed into backyard furnishings or firepit tables. 


It goes with out saying that being round a hearth can by no means be 100% protected and it is best to all the time be alert when coping with a chiminea or a hearth pit. 

It may very well be argued {that a} chiminea is safer than a hearth pit as a result of it’s extra enclosed. Nonetheless, the flames of the fireplace can solely be seen from one facet, so people behind the chiminea might not realise it has been ignited, notably if there isn’t a seen smoke. 

Then again, a hearth pit could be seen from all angles, so any particular person would concentrate on the flames from a distance. The one draw back is that embers from the fireplace can blow in all instructions if there’s a gust of wind. This isn’t the case with a chiminea as the fireplace is contained.


Each gadgets are constructed utilizing supplies that may face up to most climate circumstances. Clay chimineas might undergo harm equivalent to cracks (if they’re pushed over or dropped) however hearth pits are lengthy lasting and it’s unlikely that you’d ever want to interchange one. Take a look at our information to forged iron chimineas

Cleansing Course of

Hearth pits are straightforward to wash out with their massive open bowl form. Scooping out any ash or items of wooden is pretty easy and there’s no want to scrub it. 

Chimineas could be troublesome to wash as you must get your fingers contained in the opening to scoop out no matter is in there. Clearly, the larger the opening, the simpler it’s to filter out however this may increasingly additionally put a dent in your pockets!

Hearth Pit Execs and Cons



Determination time

Hearth pits and chimineas are an ideal addition to any backyard and the novelty hardly ever wears off. They create an ideal focus for any backyard and who doesn’t love getting wrapped in a blanket to take a seat round an open hearth with their family members?

Nonetheless, we expect that the fireplace pit takes the trophy on this competitors. They’re cheaper, extra sturdy and their ease of use wins fingers down in comparison with that of a chiminea. Each outside heaters have their professionals and cons and the choice in the end lies with your self.

For inspiration, listed here are two delicious-sounding campfire tripod recipes to strive

Pesto marinated lamb fillet

  • Sufficient lamb fillet for 4
  • 2 tbsps chopped basil
  • 1 clove garlic
  • 25g grated parmesan
  • 10g pine nuts
  • 1 tbsp virgin olive oil
  • Salt and pepper
  1. Mix the basil, the pine nuts, the garlic, the parmesan cheese and the olive oil. Use a mortar and pestle or a small blender.
  2. Set the grill grid on the tripod at a reasonable warmth. Fry the lamb fillets on the grid until nearly cooked. Unfold the pesto over the fillets and cook dinner for a few minutes longer. Serve with the ratatouille and a few good bread.


  • 1 tbsp olive oil
  • 125g chopped onion
  • 200g purple and inexperienced pepper in small items
  • 250g aubergine in small items
  • 250g sliced tomatoes
  • 250g courgettes in small items
  • 1 clove garlic, chopped
  • 1 tbsp mixture of chopped rosemary and thyme
  • Salt
  1. Put the kotlich pot over the fireplace, hanging on the tripod. Fry the onions calmly within the oil and add the opposite greens. 
  2. Simmer with the lid on till tender. Add the herbs and season to style.
  3. Grasp the pot up excessive to maintain the ratatouille heat.

kotlich campfire cooking

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Enable registration in settings - general
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Shopping cart